25th Anniversary SURF Annual Conference
Who pays? Who benefits?
Date and Venue
- CoSLA Conference Centre, 19 Haymarket Yards, Edinburgh
- Thursday 31st August 2017, 9.30am until 3.30pm
From Urban Aid to the Community Aspirations fund; via SIPs and the Fairer Scotland Fund, the Regeneration Capital Grant Fund, Urban Regeneration Companies and SPRUCE; SURF has kept working hard to support better and more cooperative regeneration policy and practice. In May this year, after 25 years of sharing experience and ideas, SURF paused to ask; ‘Does regeneration work?’ at a debate session held in Glasgow.
SURF will be further exploring the outcomes of this session and asking in a Phythonesque fashion ‘What has regeneration ever done for us?’ at this special 25th Anniversary conference.
What has changed? What’s been gained and what’s been lost? Have our collective efforts and investments so far been enough to overcome the forces of degeneration? Most importantly, what does our collective experience so far tell us about how we should address future challenges and opportunities?
We have compiled a short paper which lays out some of the background and thought process behind this year’s conference. Raising some key questions we hope will be addressed on the day.
Regneration Policy Paper
Background policy paper for the group discussion session
- 9:30am Registration, tea/coffee, music and networking
- 10:00am Welcome to the 25th Anniversary SURF Conference – SURF Chair Kate Wimpress
- 10:10am Regeneration – What has changed and what has not?
- 10:30am Regenerating Connections: a SURF perspective – Andy Milne, Chief Executive, SURF
- 10:45am Does Regeneration Work? Revisiting the debate. Q&A session with an invited Policy and Practice Panel with Ian Manson (Clyde Gateway) and Prof. Douglas Robertson – hosted by SURF Chair, Kate Wimpress
- 11:15am Coffee Break – Tea/Coffee, music and networking
- 11:45am Group Discussions ranking 12 regeneration models– What has worked historically and why? What lessons can we use to help meet future challenges? Supported by 5 Regeneration Experts and Facilitators
- 12:45pm Lunch
- 1:30pm Choose Regeneration? Film clip
- 1:40pm What works now? – Analysis and discussion of group discussion outcomes
- 1:50pm Musical Tables– Groups make a 1 minute pitch for recruits to a preferred model
- 2.30pm Panel plenary discussion – Models, resources, challenges and opportunities
- Danny Boyle – BEMIS
- Fraser Kelly – Social Enterprise Scotland
- David Cowan – Scottish Government
- David Melhuish – Scottish Property Federation
- Martin Tytler – Bute Island Alliance
- Hazel Cross – Fife Council
- 3:15pm Summary and What Next? – Andy Milne, Chief Executive, SURF
- 3:30pm Thanks and close of conference – SURF’s Kate Wimpress
- 3:30pm Close of event – tea/coffee and networking
Findings from the Annual Conference fed into an article by Derek Rankine, which was published in the Journal of Urban Regeneration and Renewal
The 2016 SURF Annual Conference
Local Poverty, National Wealth: Resourcing Regeneration 2016-21
Background and Key Themes
Like other parts of the UK, Scotland is a rich nation with too many poor people and places. Tackling poverty and inequality, while supporting inclusive economic growth, are the twin priorities for delivering regeneration over the 2016-21 Scottish Parliament term.
SURF’s 2016 Annual Conference, held on 1 September in Edinburgh, brought more than 120 participants together to explore the key question: How can we better connect challenges, resources, structures, policies and assets to help us achieve our widely shared aims for a better, fairer Scotland?
The conference featured the following sub-topics:
- Resource and strategy options
- Government policy, community delivery
- Learning from SURF’s Alliance for Action collaborations
- Rebalancing local poverty and national wealth
Morning session: Still Trickling Down?
- 9:15am Registration, coffee and networking
- 10:00am Welcome and Introduction – SURF Chair Pippa Coutts
- 10:10am 2016-21: Big Challenges, New Ideas – Robin McAlpine, Director of the Common Weal.
- 10:30am Community Reality and Resources – Sandra Marshall, Edinburgh Muirhouse Resident & Kate Wimpress, North Edinburgh Arts
- 10:45am Building a Fairer Scotland – Kevin Stewart MSP, Scottish Government Minister for Local Government and Housing
- 11:00am Questions and Comments for the Minister, Robin McAlpine, Sandra Marshall and Kate Wimpress
- 11:20am Coffee and Pastries featuring SURF Award Winners and Resilient Scotland Community Enterprise Investees with Token Gestures Coin Game
Early afternoon session: Show Us The Money: Resourcing Regeneration
- 11:40am Funding Panel: Introduced by SURF Chair Pippa Coutts with colleagues from the Big Lottery Fund in Scotland; Heritage Lottery Fund (Scotland); Highlands & Islands Enterprise; Resilient Scotland; and the Scottish Government.
- 12:15pm Questions and Debate: Funding Regeneration 2016-21
- 12:35pm Poverty, Our Hidden Shame: Short Film and Introduction by Plantation Productions Create Crew
- 12:45pm Lunch and Funding Café exhibition with representatives from 20+ regeneration funding providers, from Amber Infrastructure to Youthlink Scotland.
Late afternoon session: Making the Connections
- 1:30pm People, Policies, Partners and Places: Practical progress and learning from SURF’s Alliance for Action collaborations. Featuring Andy Milne, SURF Chief Executive, on Govan; Dr Elaine Cooper, SURF Practice & Learning Manager, on East Kirkcaldy; and Paul Duffy, Rothesay Alliance for Action Facilitator for SURF, on Rothesay, in addition to local partners.
- 2:30pm Local Poverty, National Wealth – Panel Debate with Fiona Duncan, Chief Executive, Lloyds TSB Foundation for Scotland and Robin McAlpine, Director of Common Weal.
- 3:15pm Thanks and What’s Next – SURF’s Pippa Coutts
- 3:30pm Close and coffee.
Please click on the links below to access some materials from this event:
The 2015 SURF Annual Conference
Planning Ahead for Community Regeneration
Background and Key Theme
Over 120 cross-sector guests participated in SURF’s 2015 Annual Conference, which was held in the CoSLA Conference Centre, Edinburgh, on Tuesday 25 August. The event was a key consultation activity in the development of SURF’s 2016 manifesto for community regeneration.
A draft of the manifesto was shared with delegates in advance of the one-day event. The interactive format was designed to enable delegates’ participation in the manifesto development process, including through electronic voting on existing policy recommendations, open discussion with a panel of guest experts, and a forum for suggesting and debating new ideas. The conference provided a valuable learning and networking opportunity for anyone concerned with the regeneration of Scotland’s disadvantaged communities.
The key theme was the overarching 2016 SURF manifesto objective of improving individual and community wellbeing, and the interlinked sub-topics:
- Addressing Poverty & Inequality;
- Supporting Successful Places;
- Creating a Fairer Scotland by 2030 – as per the national conversation led by the Scottish Government.
9:00am Registration, coffee and networking
9:50am Welcome – SURF Chair Pippa Coutts
10:00am Introduction and Overview – SURF Chief Executive Andy Milne
10:15am The Creating a Fairer Scotland Conversation – Scottish Government Minister for Housing and Welfare Margaret Burgess MSP
10:30am Addressing Inequality Practically – Sir Tony Atkinson, Author of ‘Inequality: What Can Be Done?’ (2015)
10:50am Questions and Comments for the Minister & Professor Atkinson
11:10am Social Justice at the Sharp End – Galgael Chair Mike McCarron with Project Participants
11:25am Coffee, Pastries and ‘Stone Tablet’ Policy Sticker Voting
11:45am SURF’s 2016 Manifesto: Key Policy Recommendations – Andy Milne
12:05pm Electronic Voting and Open Discussion
12:45pm Lunch and Further Sticker Voting
1:30pm Funny Ideas: Political Comedy from Vladimir McTavish
1.45pm Policy Recommendations from Guest Experts (with Electronic Voting):
- Labour Market: Stephen Boyd, Assistant Secretary, Scottish Trades Union Congress
- Wellbeing: Wendy Hearty, Public Health Adviser, NHS Health Scotland
- Place: Diarmaid Lawlor, Head of Urbanism, Architecture + Design Scotland
- Creative Community Participation: Kate Wimpress, Founder & Project Manager of SURF Award winning ‘North Edinburgh Grows’ initiative
2:45pm Reflections, Omissions and Connections
3:15pm Thanks and What’s Next – SURF’s Pippa Coutts
3:30pm Close and coffee
Please click on the links below to download some materials from this event, including the results of electronic voting sessions in which guests had the opportunity to rank the 18 policy recommendations from the 2nd draft of SURF’s 2016 manifesto on a sliding scale between ‘Terrible idea’ and ‘Brilliant idea’:
SURF 2016 Manifesto – Second Draft (the version presented at the Annual Conference)
Alignments Between ‘Inequality’ by Tony Atkinson and SURF’s 2016 Manifesto (a briefing paper by SURF’s Caitlin Rollison)
Health Inequalities in Scotland: Eight Action Points (SURF magazine feature by panelist Wendy Hearty)
SURF’s special 2014 Annual Conference was a follow up to SURF’s ‘one year to go’ Regeneration and the Referendum debate event of 18/09/13.
The purpose was to explore:
- Challenges for regeneration in the context of potential constitutional change.
- Opportunities for new thinking in addressing poverty and inequality.
- Four priority topics identified and explored by the SURF network:
- Degenerative Dynamics – What can be done to tackle the sometimes corrosive effects of corporate power on political systems with regard to local community interests?
- Land Ownership and Use – What rural successes and lessons in community land ownership are transferrable to urban Scotland – and how?
- Participative Democracy – Can Scotland achieve the much more local, participative and accountable decision-making that is taken for granted in many other small European countries?
- Taxing questions – What are the options for a more progressive tax system in support of social and economic regeneration?
Interactive Discussion Groups
Following lunch attendees were able to move between and input into four Interactive Discussion groups led by 4 experts- Prof Greg Lloyd (University of Ulster), David Cameron (Community Land Scotland), Dr. Oliver Escobar (Academy of Government) and Robin McAlpine (Common Weal). Please click on the titles below for summary notes from each session. The notes are a summary of the discussion and do not include a full transcript.
SURF Annual Conference 2014 Degeneration Group Discussion Notes – Prof. Greg Lloyd, University of Ulster
SURF Annual Conference Land Discussion Group Notes – David Cameron, Community Land Scotland
SURF Annual Conference Participative Democracy Discussion Notes– Dr. Oliver Escobar, Academy of Government
SURF Annual Conference 2014 Tax Discussion Group Notes– Robin McAlpine, Common Weal
On the day our attendees took part in several sessions of Electronic Voting answering questions such as “If Scotland was a comic character, which of these would it be?” We have a breakdown of all of the results which you can view by clicking on the link below.
Lost Generation – Film clip used in Katherine Trebeck, Oxfam, presentation
The Scottish Doughnut – Oxfam
Humankind Index – Oxfam
Common Weal – Robin McAlpine
Aye Right? How No? – Edinburgh Fringe Show with comedians Keir McAllister and Vladimir McTavish
2013: Creative Regeneration Background “It turns out that most neurons grow independently of each other and form synapses where they happen to bump into other cells, rather than being guided by chemical signals to find particular targets. This random process produces a more robust and adaptable brain.” Science: Contours of the Mind, Financial Times, 23 Feb 2013 The financial crash of 2008 accelerated us into the already looming demographic crisis for public services. Pre-existing levels of poverty and inequality exacerbated the degenerative impacts of the resultant recession and the poorest of Scotland’s communities are bearing the increasing burden of ‘austerity’ cuts. For its 2013 Annual Conference, held on 5 July in Edinburgh’s CoSLA Conference Centre, SURF took the opportunity to bring together senior policy makers such as Sir Peter Housden (Permanent Secretary to the Scottish Government) and Cllr David O’Neill (President of CoSLA) with community activists, artists and officials in a genuinely creative event. Keynote Presentations Please click on the titles below to download presentation slides used by some of the key conference speakers (in chronological order). In keeping with the conference theme, the presentations were mainly image-based. A forthcoming summary report will offer further elaboration, and the SURF staff team would be happy to offer immediate clarification on the speakers’ respective topics. Creating an Alliance for Action – Andy Milne, Chief Executive, SURF Culture First: Regeneration in Dundee – Stewart Murdoch, Director, Leisure & Culture Dundee Creativity in Town Centres – Malcolm Fraser, Leading Scottish Architect & Chair of External Advisory Group in the Scottish Government’s National Review of Town Centres Culture, Creativity and Resilience – Lia Ghilardi, International Cultural Planning Expert and Founder & Director, Noema Institute By Leaves We Live: Artist-Planner Collaborations – Petra Biberbach, Chief Executive, Planning Aid for Scotland Policy Foundations for Creative Approaches – Sir Peter Housden, Permanent Secretary, Scottish Government National Goals & Local Action – Cllr David O’Neill, President, Convention of Scottish Local Authorities (CoSLA) Other Materials. External Links Some of the creative works featured at the conference are available online: Creative Places – a short film showcasing the winners of the 2012 Creative Scotland awards process Glasgow 1974 – a photo series by Hugh Hood Govan Fair 2013 – a short film by Plantation Productions available on Vimeo Govan Fair 1952 – documentary footage available at the Scottish Screen Archive RIAS Awards 2013 – images of award winning Scottish architecture projects
2013: Creative Regeneration
“It turns out that most neurons grow independently of each other and form synapses where they happen to bump into other cells, rather than being guided by chemical signals to find particular targets. This random process produces a more robust and adaptable brain.”
Science: Contours of the Mind, Financial Times, 23 Feb 2013
The financial crash of 2008 accelerated us into the already looming demographic crisis for public services. Pre-existing levels of poverty and inequality exacerbated the degenerative impacts of the resultant recession and the poorest of Scotland’s communities are bearing the increasing burden of ‘austerity’ cuts.
For its 2013 Annual Conference, held on 5 July in Edinburgh’s CoSLA Conference Centre, SURF took the opportunity to bring together senior policy makers such as Sir Peter Housden (Permanent Secretary to the Scottish Government) and Cllr David O’Neill (President of CoSLA) with community activists, artists and officials in a genuinely creative event.
Please click on the titles below to download presentation slides used by some of the key conference speakers (in chronological order). In keeping with the conference theme, the presentations were mainly image-based. A forthcoming summary report will offer further elaboration, and the SURF staff team would be happy to offer immediate clarification on the speakers’ respective topics.
Creating an Alliance for Action – Andy Milne, Chief Executive, SURF
Culture First: Regeneration in Dundee – Stewart Murdoch, Director, Leisure & Culture Dundee
Creativity in Town Centres – Malcolm Fraser, Leading Scottish Architect & Chair of External Advisory Group in the Scottish Government’s National Review of Town Centres
Culture, Creativity and Resilience – Lia Ghilardi, International Cultural Planning Expert and Founder & Director, Noema Institute
By Leaves We Live: Artist-Planner Collaborations – Petra Biberbach, Chief Executive, Planning Aid for Scotland
Policy Foundations for Creative Approaches – Sir Peter Housden, Permanent Secretary, Scottish Government
National Goals & Local Action – Cllr David O’Neill, President, Convention of Scottish Local Authorities (CoSLA)
Some of the creative works featured at the conference are available online:
Creative Places – a short film showcasing the winners of the 2012 Creative Scotland awards process
Glasgow 1974 – a photo series by Hugh Hood
Govan Fair 2013 – a short film by Plantation Productions available on Vimeo
Govan Fair 1952 – documentary footage available at the Scottish Screen Archive
RIAS Awards 2013 – images of award winning Scottish architecture projects
Reality, Resources, Resilience: Regeneration in a Recession
Surgeon’s Hall, Edinburgh
This conference brought together over 130 policy makers, academics, regeneration practitioners and community volunteers from SURF’s diverse and extensive networks across Scotland to discuss the future for community regeneration.
The content of the event was based on a programme of collaborative work that SURF developed in cooperation with the Joseph Rowntree Foundation with support for the Scottish Government.
The varied and interactive programme was designed to help share experience and transfer knowledge across different sectors and borders, and in particular to:
- Debate perceptions of ‘reality’ in changing times and the shared challenges for regeneration
- Explore resources at hand and how we can link up with those that are less obvious
- Promote resilience for both sustaining and evolving regeneration efforts
Download the full 2012 Conference Report.
Dr Gerry McCartney, Head of Public Health Observatory Division in NHS Health Scotland, on ‘Healthy Economics?’
Meg Peterson, Arts Project Manager, Cultural Planner, Educator and Visual Artist, Cultural Planner, Educator and Visual Artist, on ‘International Perspectives: Art and Culture in Chicago’ – and please click here for the second set of slides. NB these two PDF documents are 9 and 10 megabytes respectively.
Andy Milne, Chief Executive of SURF, on ‘Community Reality’
Please click on the links below to download presentation slides used by representatives of the following funding organisations, who provided an overview of their regeneration investment streams.
- Amber Infrastructure/ESEP Ltd (SPRUCE)
- Big Lottery Fund (Scotland)
- Heritage Lottery Fund (Scotland)
- Scottish Communities Foundation (JESSICA (Scotland) Trust)
- Scottish Government (People & Communities Fund)
Electronic Voting Results
Download the electronic voting results.
Download the delegates list.
Download the conference programme.
Key Speaker Biographies
Please click here for speaker biographies, including Alex Neil MSP, Dr Gerry McCartney, Meg Peterson, Andy Milne, guest chair Andrew Lyon (International Futures Forum) and ‘community reality’ participants Karen McGregor (Gallatown & East Sinclairtown Tenants and Residents Association) and Gehan Macleod (Galgael).
Supporting Resilient Communities
Roxburghe Hotel, Edinburgh
Delivered with support from NHS Health Scotland
The previous SURF Annual Conference highlighted the collapse of the property-based model of delivering community regeneration, and the need for more creative approaches.
The public sector cuts that followed since increased the pressures on already vulnerable communities. The challenges for community regeneration policy and practice are considerable.
The purpose of this event was to improve cross-sector understanding and cooperation in supporting more resilient communities at a point of great change.
Over 130 participants, including community representatives, regeneration practitioners, policy-makers and academics from across the country and beyond, attended the event to share experience and transfer knowledge on promoting resilience in adversity.
Please click here to download the full 2011 Conference Report highlighting all of the main learning outcomes that emerged from the event.
Julia Unwin, Chief Executive of the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, on ‘Community Resilience and Poverty’
Andy Milne, Chief Executive of SURF, on ‘National Priorities’
George Dodds, Director of Programme Design and Delivery, NHS Health Scotland, NHS Health Scotland
Denys Candy, international creative regeneration practitioner, on ‘A Transatlantic View’
John Cassidy, community volunteer, on ‘Resilience and Community Participation’
Andrew Lyon, Converger of the International Futures Forum, in his opening introduction
Please click here to download a note of the key points from the six themed and facilitiated discussion groups. The topics were:
- Active Communities & Resilient Legal Structures
- Health, Value & Property Procurement
- Housing, Health and Regeneration
- Human Rights
- Place, Culture & Resilience
- Valuing Wellbeing
Electronic Voting Results
Please click here to download the results from the conference voting sessions
Please click here for a copy of the event delegate list
Key Speaker Biographies
Please click here for background details on the key speakers
Sustaining and Reinventing Community Regeneration
In a time of economic inactivity, dramatic reductions in public spending, and rising levels of unemployment and poverty, the 2010 SURF Annual Conference looked squarely at the challenges ahead. The focus of the two-day event was on linking people, projects and practice across the SURF network to examine the real opportunities for supporting more sustainable community regeneration in a time of major change.
In cooperation with the Public Policy Network of the University of Edinburgh, the first day of the conference linked Scotland’s extensive regeneration oriented academic resources with the practical challenges at hand for practitioners and policy-makers. The guest chair was Prof. Greg Lloyd, Head of School of the Built Environment at the University of Ulster.
The second day focused on cooperation in policy and practice. Key speakers, debates, presentations and panel sessions linked the policy process to the realities of delivering positive change in Scotland’s most disadvantaged communities. In doing so, the assets and resources that are at hand to support and sustain regeneration were showcased. The guest chair for day two was Jim McCormick, Scotland Adviser for the Joseph Rowntree Foundation.
Full Conference Report
Please click here to download the full 2010 Conference Report. Speaker presentation slides and other materials are available for download below.
The Role of Research in a Flourishing Scotland by Dominic Munro, Director of Communities Analytical Services Division in the Scottish Government.
An International Perspective by Professor Duncan Maclennan, international housing and regeneration expert and Director of the Centre for Housing Research in the University of St. Andrews.
National Priorities – Local Delivery by Kath Beveridge, Head of Community Planning and Regeneration in Aberdeen City Council.
A Shared Enterprise by Jim McFarlane, Managing Director of Operations in Scottish Enterprise.
National Government Support’ by Mike Foulis, Director of the Housing and Regeneration Directorate in the Scottish Government.
Please click here for a ‘constructive debates’ paper, which contains ten short articles from leading regeneration experts in the policy areas of housing, poverty, public services, master-planning and community assets.
Please click here for a delegates list for both days of the conference.
Health, Wellbeing and Regeneration in a Cold Climate
The West Park Centre, Dundee
In recent years, SURF has been working to promote the links between the regeneration and health agendas in Scotland, and at our 2008 Annual Conference, it was asserted that, “health and wellbeing is the point of regeneration, not just a factor in it.”
With that in mind, and with a view to supporting ongoing national and local government efforts to support a ‘flourishing’ Scotland, despite a difficult economic climate, SURF adopted the linkages between health, wellbeing and regeneration as the main focus of our 2009 Annual Conference.
The purpose of this event, attended by 120 guests in Dundee, was to explore options for linking health and regeneration agendas in promoting wellbeing. The one-day event featured expert keynote speakers, a wide range of topical discussion groups, and lots of interactive activity.
SURF is very grateful to all speakers, discussion group facilitators and participants for their input. A full conference report, keynote presentation slides and related materials are available for download below:
Download the 2009 Conference Report.
Keynote Presentations (all in PDF format)
- Supporting Local Delivery by Kay Barton Head of Health Improvement Strategy in the Scottish Government.
- Northerly Approaches by Thor Rogan by Thor Rogan, Deputy Director General of the Norwegian Ministry of Health and Care Services.
- Success in the Community by Wendy Drysdale (Co-ordinator) and Natalie Martin (Volunteer) of the ‘Community Mothers South’ project highlighted in the 2008 SURF Awards.
- The Health Impacts of Place on Wellbeing by Ade Kearns, Professor of Urban Studies in the University of Glasgow and Principal Investigator of the GoWell project.
- Building Positive Links to Wellbeing by Allyson McCollamChief Executive of the Scottish Development Centre for Mental Health.
Discussion Group Feedback
Please click to read the discussion group feedback from the six policy discussion groups, which were:
- Health, Sport and Regeneration. Guest speaker: Stewart Harris, Chief Executive of sportscotland.
- Healthy Places. Guest speaker: Deryck Irving, Partnership and Enabling Manager, Greenspace Scotland.
- Healthy Outcomes and the Role of Local Authorities. Further background materiel on healthy outcomes provided by guest speaker Stewart Murdoch, Director of Leisure and Communities, Dundee City Council.
- Local Links. Guest speaker: John Quinn, General Manager, Craigmillar URC.
- Healthy Democracy – Beyond Community Engagement. Guest speaker: Fraser Patrick, Associate Lecturer, University of Dundee.
- Early Intervention. Guest speaker: Tom Woods, special adviser on early intervention at the Capital City Partnership.
View the electronic voting from the morning session.
“Plus ca change…”
1992-2022: A Generation of Regeneration
“Be the change”
The West Park Centre, Dundee
The Scottish Urban Regeneration Forum was established in 1992. A lot has changed since then, and a lot has stayed the same. To celebrate our 15th Anniversary, this special Annual Conference presented an excellent opportunity to learn from the past in order to help us see how we can meet the challenges of the next 15 years.
150 SURF members and regeneration stakeholders attended the Conference, which included:
- presentations from four keynote speakers
- policy discussion groups with a panel of experts
- and other interactive elements including plenary debates and delegates’ electronic voting sessions.
You can download the full 2008 Annual Conference Report in PDF format. Further materials are available for download below.
- Academic and Former special advisor, Adrian Colwell – Learning from Experience Download Adrian’s presentation
- Professor David North on his JRF-backed study of Devolution and Tackling Deprivation Download Professor North’s presentation
- Writer and Academic Professor Chris Harvie – A Future Scotland Download Professor Harvie’s presentation notes
- Mike Foulis, Director of Housing and Regeneration in the Scottish Government – Towards Sustainable Communities Download Mike’s presentation
Delegates’ Voting Session
Policy Discussion Groups
Carol Young, Scottish Low Pay Unit
Laurie Russell, The Wise Group
Matthew Crighton, Capital City Partnership
Mike O’Donnell, Scottish Government
Chair: David Coulter, Scottish Enterprise
Della Thomas, Health Scotland
Geoff Huggins, Scottish Government
Janet Muir, Community Health Exchange
Allyson McCollam, SDC for Mental Health
Chair: Anne Clarke, NHS Ayrshire & Arran
Skills and Learning
Maggi Allan, formerly of Curriculum for Excellence
Phil Denning, HM Inspectorate of Education
Sandy Campbell, Working Rite
Jonathan Sher, Children in Scotland
Chair: Paul Ballantyne, Scottish Centre for Regeneration
Stephen Maxwell, SCVO
Pauline Gallacher, Neilston Community Trust
Wilma Dunca, Dundee Community Regeneration Fund
Angus Hardie, DTA Scotland
Chair: Colin Armstrong, Housing Consultant
SURF did not hold an Annual Conference in 2007.
Regeneration – The Right Stuff (Do we have it? And would we recognise it anyway?) –
West Park Centre, Dundee
The general topic of our 2006 conference, held in Dundee, was: do we have the right policies, mechanisms and organisations in place, and linked up, to deliver successful community based regeneration in Scotland?
SURF is particularly grateful for the generous additional support we received from The Joseph Rowntree Foundation and Communities Scotland. This enabled us to ensure that a substantial number of community representatives could be involved in the conference at no cost. We also appreciate the time that the community representatives themselves took to participate in the event and contribute to the lively debate there.
Around this theme, we provided the opportunity for a broad range of discussion within the following context:
- The Scottish Executive’s revised regeneration statement
- Community Planning is being developed across Scotland as the Executive’s main policy for tackling poverty and regenerating some of the most disadvantaged communities
- With the end of Social Inclusion Partnerships, what is the future for local community leadership and empowerment as distinct from community consultation and engagement?
- Have we the right structures for optimising the trade off between social and economic regeneration?
- Renewed interest in the role of cities in neighbourhood and regional regeneration
- Continuing discussions regarding the level of political and practical support for social enterprise and community asset building.
- What new links can be built between Culture and Regeneration?
- To what extent is employment the best answer to the main impacts of poverty?
- Neighbourhood regeneration; is it being ‘mainstreamed’ or ‘sidelined’ within wider strategies?
Contributors included Malcolm Chisholm MSP, Minister for Communities and Dermot Finch, Director of IPPR’s Centre for Cities. In addition to listening to speakers, delegates were able to take advantage of interactive elements within the conference, including a series of chaired panel discussions and the use of an electronic voting system.
The voting results make for interesting reading and are available here:
A full annual Conference 2006 report is also available.
Presentation slides from a selection of speakers can be downloaded below (click on the presenter’s name for access):
- “Successful Regeneration in C21st Scotland – what will it take? A personal view” – Professor Stuart Gulliver of Glasgow University
- “People and Leadership in Cities” – Dermot Finch (Director) & Chris Urwin (Economist), IPPR’s Centre for Cities
- “Community Support. Supporting community capacity to be involved and to lead” – David Tyler, Director, Community Matters
- “Keeping the Community in Community Regeneration” – Archie Thomson, community activist
- “Innovation or Institutional clutter?” – Professor Professor Greg Lloyd of Dundee University’s Geddes Institute
- “The Same but Different: Delivering regeneration on both sides of the border” – Helen Forsyth, Regeneration Director of Places for People: Part One, Part Two & Part Three (Unfortunately Helen was unable to attend the conference and this presentation was not given on the day)
List of Delegates attending the conference.
SURF did not hold an Annual Conference in 2005.
Leadership and Community Planning
West Park Centre, Dundee
The 2004 Annual Conference united two key current themes in regeneration; Leadership and Community Planning. This built upon the outcomes of the ‘Leadership in Regeneration’ seminar held earlier in the year, and the ongoing work undertaken in supporting the development of the nation network for Community Planning Partnerships.
Speakers included Zoe Van Zwanenberg of the Scottish Leadership Foundation, speaking on broad leadership contexts; Jack Davies, Chief Executive of the South Kilburn New Deal for Communities Project, on leadership in the practical regeneration context; Richard Scothorne of Rocket Science, providing a summary of the key points from the morning session and their relevance to current challenges; and Mary Mulligan Deputy Minister for Communities, on the leading role of the Scottish Executive.
SURF did not hold an Annual Conference in 2003.
2020 Visions: The Future for Communities
St Andrews in the Square, Glasgow
This conference asked a number of visionary thinkers to set out their views on how our communities will work and feel in 2020. They outlined their views on what changes will have taken place and put forward their ideas on the implications that these have for decision making now. Questions to considered included: what types of organisation and people could develop communities? What could the places we live and work in be like? How could changes in society and culture affect the way in which communities work? What could be the implications of advances in technology? What could be the economic factors we need to be aware of? So, where do we go now? Speakers included Lord Richard Best, Director, Joseph Rowntree Foundation; Tom Bentley, Director, Demos; Heather Koronka, Director of Regeneration, Communities Scotland; Jim McCormick, Research Director, Scottish Council Foundation; Gregor Rae, Chair and Co-Founder, Business Lab; and Julian Dobson, Editor, New Start magazine.
Ewan Mearns’ Powerpoint Presentation
Regeneration and Inclusion: Learning from Seven Countries
James Watt Centre II, Edinburgh
SURF’s 3rd Annual Conference was held on 2 November in Edinburgh examining the theme of “Regeneration and Inclusion: Learning from 7 Countries”. The conference attempted to look at how these issues were being dealt with across the UK and the rest of the world focusing on the 3 ‘Ps’ of regeneration: people, places and partnership. Given this, speakers included Lulu Gwagwa, Chief Executive of Independent Development Trust in South Africa; Ted Wysocki, Chief Executive of Chicago Association of Neighbourhood Development Organisations, USA; Lynne Cunningham, Chief Executive of Southeast Chicago Development Company, USA; Lykke Leonardsen, Co-ordinator, Kongens Enghave Kvaerterloft, Denmark; Jon Bright, Head of Programmes, Neighbourhood Renewal Unit, DTLR, England; Norma Barry, Head of Communities Directorate, National Assembly of Wales; Eddie Hayes, Department of Social Development, Northern Irish Assembly; Jackie Baillie MSP, Minister for Social Justice, Scottish Executive; and Bob Millar, Chief Executive, Communities Scotland.
The Burrell Museum, Glasgow
This conference examined the current arrangements involved in taking a co-ordinated approach regeneration in the hope that in pointing out examples of excellence as well as problems would help further improve practice over the coming years. It looked at several aspects of ‘joined upness’ including joint working between sectors, agencies, geographical areas, political administrations and disciplines. Featuring keynote presentation from the Minister for Social Justice, Jackie Baillie MSP and other presentations from Keith Whitefield of Wester Hailes Representative Council; Andrew Lyon, Acting Chief of Forward Scotland, Niall McGilp, Director, Competitive Place, Scottish Enterprise; Clive Dutton, Head of Regeneration in Sandwell Metropolitan Borough Council; and Michael Chapman of Heriot Watt University/ Edinburgh School of Art.
URBAN SCOTLAND: CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES
Heriot Watt University, Edinburgh
Featuring keynote presentation from Jackie Baillie MSP, Deputy Minister for Communities and other presentations from Michael Burns of the Castlemilk Economic Development Agency; Baillie Stephen Purcell of Glasgow City Council; Professor Michael Carley of Heriot Watt University; Kevin Murray of EDAW Ltd; James McCormick of the Scottish Council Foundation; Graeme Pearson of Strathclyde Police; John Low of Joseph Rowntree Foundation and Margaret Curran MSP, Convenor of the Scottish Parliament Committee on Social Inclusion, Housing and the Voluntary Sector.